نوع مقاله : پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Article 241 of the Iranian Code of Civil Procedure entrusts judges with assessing the probative value of witness testimony without establishing specific statutory criteria, thereby creating scope for subjective factors and cognitive biases to influence judicial evaluation. Employing a descriptive-analytical method and drawing on findings from cognitive and forensic psychology, this study addresses the following question: How does the absence of objective criteria in Article 241 facilitate the emergence of cognitive biases in assessing the credibility of witness testimony, and what measures can reduce their influence and enhance the objectivity and reliability of judicial evaluation? The findings indicate that cognitive biases, including confirmation bias, the halo effect, anchoring bias, availability bias, and overconfidence, may distort credibility assessments and allow personal perceptions to influence judicial decisions. Accordingly, the study emphasizes the need to establish specific statutory criteria, including the quality of perception and opportunity for direct observation, the process of recollection, consistency and stability of statements, corroboration by other evidence and circumstantial indicators, potential personal motives, and psychological factors affecting perception and memory. Furthermore, requiring judges to provide reasoned and evidence-based explanations for accepting or rejecting testimony, training judges in cognitive psychology, developing standardized witness-evaluation checklists, and employing artificial intelligence systems as judicial decision-support tools under judicial supervision may help mitigate cognitive biases, enhance transparency and consistency in witness evaluation, and improve the quality of judicial reasoning.
کلیدواژهها English