نوع مقاله : پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The emergence of digital commercial platforms as actors beyond mere passive intermediaries has challenged the theoretical foundations of criminal law and limited the explanatory power of the classical concepts of the actus reus in relation to algorithmic, networked, and anonymous behaviors. The central question is whether the inadequacy of Iran’s criminal policy toward Platform Crimes is merely legislative and judicial, or also has a conceptual root in the actus reus, and which concepts should be completed or redefined. Employing a qualitative method with a descriptive-analytical approach, this article draws on a systematic study of sources, content analysis of 73 judicial verdicts, semi-structured interviews with 17 judicial officials. The findings indicate that Iran’s criminal policy, both at the legislative level (with the outdated Computer Crimes Law of 2009) and at the judicial level (divergence of judicial opinions, the absence of platforms from the sphere of accountability, and difficulties in applying the territoriality criterion), is ineffective in establishing the criminal conduct of platforms, and that recurring patterns in the data point to a conceptual root. The article concludes that concepts such as act, complicity, and corporate liability remain adequate in many cases, whereas omission, causation, and the determination of the place of crime require legislative completion; only in a limited domain are novel concepts such as “architecture-oriented conduct” and “data-act” necessary, with clear attribution criteria and within the framework of the principle of legality. Algorithmic mens rea and risk-based liability, by contrast, concern the mental element and the basis of liability rather than the actus reus.
کلیدواژهها English