The Judiciarys Law Journal

The Judiciarys Law Journal

The Cases and Effects of Unenforceable Final Judgment

Author
Abdollah khodabakhshi
Department of law, faculty of Law and political science, ferdowsi university of mashhad, mashhad, iran
10.22106/jlj.2019.35487
Abstract
The purpose of the proceeding and the issuance of judgment is the determination of the legal solution and it's performance between the parties. However sometimes for various reasons, there is no way to perform the judgment. This means that the enforcement of the judgment may be in conflict with the rights of third parties or its subject may be changed or administrative obstacles cause to cease the execution of it. In some cases, the enforcement of judgment also needs to preconditions that it can't be established and implemented without the independent proceeding and with respect to the right of defense. In fact, the principles of due process for example the hearing parties statement, giving the opportunity to defense and the complaint against the court decision must be followed also in the enforcement stage and Hence, sometimes it must be stopped the enforcement of judgment. These cases have not a certain criteria in jurisprudence. One of the its reasons is the lack of supervision of excellent authorities over the executive orders because most decisions in the implementation stage are through administrative orders and the beneficiary can't complain about them. Due to defect in the legal literature (doctrine) and fitful jurisprudence, the effects of unenforceability of judgment exactly are not clear. In fact, the main question is, can it be possible to enforce a definitive judgment? And if the answer is positive, what is the criterion of it? It seems there are exceptions in judicial review to failure for implementing of definitive judgments and seems the most important criterion can be seen in practical problems and changing the subject of judgment. Hence in the present article, these issues will be considered.
Keywords
Judgment
Enforceability of judgment
Stay of execution
Difficulty of enforcement
-         اسدى‏ حلى(علامه)، حسن‏، تذکره الفقهاء، چاپ اول‏، قم، مؤسسه آل البیت علیهم السلام‏، 1388 ق.
-         بحرالعلوم، محمد، بلغه‌الفقیه، جلد 2، چاپ چهارم‏، تهران، منشورات مکتبه الصادق‏، 1403 ق.
-         خدابخشی، عبدالله، حقوق حاکم بر اجرای آرای مدنی، چاپ اول، شرکت سهامی انتشار، 1393.
-         ـــــــــــــــــــ ، حقوق دعاوی: تحلیل حقوقی روایات، چاپ اول، شرکت سهامی انتشار، 1395.
-         رشتى، میرزا حبیب‌الله، فقه الامامیه: قسم الخیارات، چاپ اول، قم، کتابفروشى داورى‏، 1407 ق.
-         ــــــــــــــــــــــــــ ، کتاب الغصب، چاپ اول، موسسه تحقیقات و نشر معارف اهل البیت، 1322 ق.
-         مامقانى، محمد، غایه‌الآمال فی شرح کتاب المکاسب‏، جلد 2، چاپ اول‏، قم، مجمع الذخائر الإسلامیه، 1316 ق.
-         مروج جزائرى، سید محمدجعفر، هدى الطالب فی شرح المکاسب، جلد ‌3، قم، مؤسسه دارالکتاب، 1416 ق.
-         مهاجری، علی، شرح جامع قانون اجرای احکام مدنی، جلد اول و دوم، انتشارات فکرسازان، چاپ پنجم، 1390.
-         مولابیگی، غلامرضا، صلاحیت و آیین دادرسی دیوان عدالت اداری، چاپ دوم، انتشارات جنگل، 1394.
-         نهرینی، فریدون، ایستایی اجرای حکم دادگاه، انتشارات گنج دانش، 1392.
-        هاشمی‌ شاهرودی، سیدمحمود؛ و جمعی از پژوهشگران، فرهنگ فقه مطابق مذهب اهل بیت علیهم‌السلام، جلد 2، قم، مؤسسه دائره‌المعارف فقه اسلامى، 1426 ق.
 
-       Enforcement of Court Decisions in Europe, Report Prepared by the Research Team on Enforcement of Court Decisions, University Nancy (France), Swiss Institute of Comparative Law and Discussed by the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL at their 8th Meeting.
-       European Commission’s Directorate General Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality, Case Study on the Functioning of Enforcement Proceedings Relating to Judicial Decisions in Member States, 1st Edition, 2015.
-       Kahneman, Daniel, Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, 1st Edition, Cambridge University Press, 1982.
-       Frisch, Deborah, "The Effect of Ambiguity on Judgment and Choice", University of Pennsylvania, 1988, Paper AAI8824738.

  • Receive Date 21 March 2019
  • First Publish Date 21 March 2019
  • Publish Date 21 March 2019